Did Jonah Die in the Belly of the Fish?
We have been having a class on Jonah and the teacher is trying to make the case that Jonah died while in the belly of the fish. He is basing his assumption on Jonah 2:2-6 then again in Matt 12:38-40 saying that both Jonah and Christ died and was then resurrected. I don’t believe that Jonah died. I believe that God kept him alive to teach him and us that his will will be done and that he cares for all people and allows all to repent. I also believe that the sign of Jonah was, as Christ stated, that he was in the belly of the great fish for three days and three nights as he was buried for three days and nights. What are your thoughts? ~ Marvin Towell I thought I’d been around – both here and there as well for several decades – but I don’t recall having heard about anyone teaching that Jonah died while inside the “great fish” (Jonah 1:17). The notion took me a little by surprise. Nevertheless, the question of whether Jonah died while in the belly of the great fish deserves examination. After looking at a great number of biblical resources, I was about to conclude that no reference work of which I was aware theorized Jonah died while in the belly of the great fish. Then, I came across Burton Coffman’s commentary on Jonah 2:2, in which place he cited commentators who were certain that Jonah died in the belly …